What Is a Good Cash on Cash Return for Rental Property?

A good cash on cash return is 8-12% for most rental properties. Here's what affects CoC, how to calculate it, and when to accept lower returns.

By Amanda Orson
Published
Updated
A good cash on cash return is 8 to 12% for most rental properties.

A good cash on cash return for rental property is 8-12%, meaning your annual cash flow equals 8-12% of the total cash you invested. That beats stock market averages while accounting for the added effort and risk of real estate.

What Cash on Cash Return Measures

Cash on cash (CoC) return measures how much cash income your invested dollars produce each year.

Formula: (Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow ÷ Total Cash Invested) × 100

Example:

  • You invest $50,000 (down payment + closing costs + initial repairs)
  • Property generates $5,400/year in cash flow ($450/month)
  • Cash on cash return: $5,400 ÷ $50,000 = 10.8%

Your $50,000 earns 10.8% annually in pure cash flow, not counting appreciation, principal paydown, or tax benefits. Use our rental property calculator to run your own numbers.

Why 8-12% Is the Target Range

Below 8%, your capital earns similar returns in index funds without the headaches of tenants, maintenance, and vacancy. The S&P 500 has averaged 10% annually over the past 50 years.

At 6% CoC: You're accepting landlord responsibilities for stock market returns, and the only justification is a heavy bet on appreciation.

At 8-10% CoC: You're beating passive investments while building equity through principal paydown and potential appreciation, which is a reasonable risk-adjusted return.

At 12%+ CoC: This is strong performance. Either you found an excellent deal, you're in a high-yield market, or your assumptions are too optimistic.

At 15%+ CoC: Double-check your math and make sure you've included vacancy, CapEx reserves, and realistic maintenance, because projections above 15% usually drop to 10% in reality.

Cash on Cash by Market Type

Different markets produce different CoC expectations:

Market TypeTypical CoCExamples
Cash flow markets10-14%Memphis, Cleveland, Indianapolis, Birmingham
Balanced markets7-10%Dallas, Atlanta, Charlotte, Phoenix
Appreciation markets3-7%Austin, Denver, Nashville, Portland
Coastal/high-cost1-5%San Francisco, LA, NYC, Seattle

In Memphis, you can find 12% CoC properties because purchase prices are low relative to rents. In San Francisco, even 5% CoC is rare because prices are astronomical relative to rents.

Neither is inherently better. Cash flow markets generate income now, while appreciation markets bet on equity growth later, so your strategy should determine your market.

What Affects Cash on Cash Return

1. Purchase Price Relative to Rent

The lower your purchase price relative to rent, the higher your CoC. This is why the 1% rule exists: properties meeting 1% rent-to-price typically generate 8%+ CoC.

2. Down Payment Size

Larger down payments lower your mortgage payment and increase cash flow, but they also increase cash invested. The effect on CoC depends on your interest rate.

Example on a $200,000 purchase at 7.43% (the national average for a 30-year fixed mortgage as of October 2026):

Down PaymentCash InvestedMonthly Cash FlowAnnual CoC
20% ($40,000)$45,000$2336.2%
25% ($50,000)$55,000$3036.6%
30% ($60,000)$65,000$3726.9%

A bigger down payment means more cash flow but also more capital at risk, so choose the balance that fits your reserves and how many more properties you plan to buy.

3. Interest Rate

Higher rates cut cash flow sharply. A property that generated 12% CoC at 4% rates might generate 6% CoC at 7.43%, the October 2026 average for a 30-year fixed, with the same rent and the same purchase price.

The math: Every 1% increase in mortgage rate reduces monthly cash flow by roughly $60-70 per $100,000 borrowed.

4. Operating Expenses

Property taxes, insurance, and HOA fees vary widely. A $150,000 property in Texas (2.5% property tax) has $3,750/year in taxes, while the same property in Arizona (0.6% tax) has $900/year. That's a $2,850/year difference, which can swing CoC by 5-6%.

5. Your Vacancy and CapEx Assumptions

If you model 0% vacancy, your CoC looks great. Reality delivers 5-8% vacancy in most markets. For the full expense picture, see our guide on how to analyze a rental property. The same goes for CapEx, since ignoring reserves inflates CoC projections.

Investors often claim 15% CoC on paper and then complain about "unexpected" expenses eating their cash flow, when the real problem was that their projections were unrealistic.

Calculating Cash on Cash: Complete Example

Property: $180,000 purchase, $1,600/month rent

ItemCalculationAnnual Amount
Cash Invested
Down payment (25%)$180,000 × 0.25$45,000
Closing costs (3%)$180,000 × 0.03$5,400
Initial repairs$3,000
Total Cash Invested$53,400
Income
Gross rent$1,600 × 12$19,200
Less vacancy (5%)$19,200 × 0.05-$960
Effective Gross Income$18,240
Expenses
Mortgage (P&I)$135,000 loan, 7.43%, 30yr$11,250
Property taxes$2,700
Insurance$1,400
Property management (8%)$18,240 × 0.08$1,459
Repairs (1% of value)$180,000 × 0.01$1,800
CapEx reserves (1%)$180,000 × 0.01$1,800
Total Expenses$20,409
Annual Cash Flow$18,240 - $20,409-$2,169
Cash on Cash Return-$2,169 ÷ $53,400-4.1%

This property doesn't cash flow at current rates with full expense loading. Either negotiate a lower price, find higher rent, or walk away.

Use our cash on cash calculator to run your own numbers.

When to Accept Lower Cash on Cash

A sub-8% CoC isn't automatically a bad deal. Consider:

Strong appreciation potential. A 5% CoC property in a market growing 8% annually builds wealth through equity, and in 5 years appreciation may be far larger than cash flow. Measure the full picture with equity multiple: it captures total return including cash flow and sale proceeds.

Exceptional quality. A newer property in an A-class neighborhood may generate lower CoC but deliver lower vacancy, better tenants, and fewer repairs. Total return matters more than cash flow alone.

Tax benefits. Depreciation, mortgage interest deductions, and potential 1031 exchanges add returns that CoC doesn't capture.

Portfolio diversification. Your 8th property might be a 6% CoC deal in a different market to reduce geographic concentration.

But be honest with yourself: if you're accepting 5% CoC, you're making an appreciation bet. If appreciation doesn't materialize, you underperformed passive index funds while doing landlord work.

Tracking Actual Cash on Cash

Projected CoC is a guess, and only your actual CoC tells you how the property really performed.

Track every property's real cash flow against original investment using a cash flow analysis. After year one, calculate:

Actual CoC = Actual Cash Flow ÷ Total Cash Invested

Actual results can land on either side of the projection. For example, a property projected at 10% CoC might deliver 12% because vacancy came in lower than expected, while another projected at 10% delivers 6% because repairs ran higher and rent grew more slowly.

Operator shows cash-on-cash for every property you own in one dashboard, and checks your rents against the market every month so you can see when a unit is dragging your return down.


FAQ

What is a good cash on cash return on rental property?

A good cash on cash return is 8-12% for most rental properties. Below 8%, your capital could earn similar returns in passive index funds. Above 12% is excellent but verify your assumptions; projections above 15% often use unrealistic vacancy or expense estimates. Cash flow markets like Memphis and Cleveland typically yield 10-14%, while appreciation markets like Austin or Denver yield 3-7%.

How do you calculate cash on cash return?

Cash on cash return = (Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow ÷ Total Cash Invested) × 100. Annual cash flow is rent collected minus all expenses including mortgage, taxes, insurance, management, vacancy, repairs, and CapEx reserves. Total cash invested includes down payment, closing costs, and any initial repairs or improvements.

Is 7% cash on cash return good?

A 7% cash on cash return is acceptable but not strong. It slightly underperforms long-term stock market averages (10%) while requiring active management. At 7% CoC, the deal may still make sense if the property offers strong appreciation potential, below-average vacancy risk, or significant tax benefits. In high-cost coastal markets, 7% CoC may be above average.

Built for this

Operator runs your buy box every day and sends you only the new matches, including off-market properties. It calculates NOI and DSCR for any address, shows cap rate and cash-on-cash for the properties you own, and checks your rents against the market every month. Plans start at $49/mo with a 7-day free trial.

Explore Buy Box Agent
operator.galleon.io/buy-box

North Jersey 5–8

5–8 units · ≤ $1.6M · Cap ≥ 6.5%
Sample listings matching the North Jersey 5–8 buy box
18 Grove StreetPaterson, NJ
$945K1857.80%$74K52dNew
412 Hawthorne AveNewark, NJ
$1.19M1917.40%$88K61dNew
1144 Market StreetPaterson, NJ
$980K1817.20%$71K54dReviewing
27 Elm StreetJersey City, NJ
$1.42M1926.90%$98K83dReviewing
901 Broad StreetNewark, NJ
$1.26M1836.60%$83K79dUnder offer